College students don't need to pay anybody for old essays if they just want them as examples of how other students have fulfilled assignments. In fact, many professors actually distribute previous examples and even most of those who don't do this will happily provide them to any student who requests them. If students really want old essays only as "examples," they can always get them from their social networks at school. College students have been sharing their old essays with one another this way for generations, and long before digital social networking vastly expanded their social networks beyond immediate in-person acquaintances. Typically, they've always gotten them from friends who already took the same course or from the vast libraries of old essays maintained by every fraternity on every college campus, often categorized by year, topic, and even by specific professors. Nobody really needs to purchase old essays from commercial essay companies when one can easily find old essays right on campus that were actually used in the same course and that received good grades from the same professor. If their intended use is perfectly legitimate and only what's allowed by professors and by institutional student codes of ethics, there's really no reason to go outside of your own college campus for "examples" of good essays.
They read the old paper, some of the information is bound to stick to stick and find its way into the new paper. That isn't plagiarism, that is an education.
Actually, this is rank plagiarism by every known academic standard defining plagiarism. If they use any idea from any source without citing and referencing that source, it's plagiarism and if a professor notices that something in your essay was derived from a previous student's paper, it's not going to help you to tell the professor that you didn't mean to plagiarize, but a few ideas from the old essay that you read just "stuck" in your head and "found their way" into your essay. If previously-written papers still had any commercial value -- which is precisely what we're discussing here -- the bottom wouldn't have, essentially, fallen through the floor for essay companies that did a lot of business selling old essays prior to 2007 when turnitin first came on board. Likewise, if old papers still had anywhere even close to the same value to students that they had prior to 2007, the market for original essays wouldn't have exploded the way it did, starting right around the same time (2007). The simple truth is that the vast majority of the millions of college students who have used old papers in the last 100+ years used them to copy and re-purpose parts of them
instead of doing their own original writing. Until 2007, many if not
most customers in this industry got away with the cheaper option by purchasing pre-written essays. Since plagiarism scanning became routine in academia, there's almost no commercial market remaining for pre-written papers, precisely because they have so much less value to students.
As a college student, don't you remember the experience of getting an essay or research paper assignment, or having to turn in a term paper, without having any idea how to go about researching and writing it?
Of course I do; that's exactly why I recounted that experience in significant detail in my Review thread right on this forum: I want my clients to know that I understand what they're going through and that even (some) people who were very intimidated by writing assignments in college eventually became good, confident, and even
prolific writers. It's absolutely none of my business what my clients choose to do with the work they purchase from me (whose copyrights they own exclusively) and I'm not criticizing anybody for whatever he or she does with respect to fulfilling college writing assignments. I'm simply explaining that from the commercial perspective, pre-written essays have almost zero value nowadays, precisely because the vast majority of students who use pre-written essays
don't use them in ways that are condoned by their professors or permitted by institutional student codes of ethics. If they did, I don't know that I'd be able to make a decent living selling original custom essays.