The current obsession with AI as the "perfect" writing companion is, frankly, exhausting. There is a certain soul-crushing sterility in normalizing the use of technology for every creative and academic endeavor. We are teaching students to outsource their thoughts before they've even learned how to form them on the page.
We also need to stop the cycle of funneling students toward high-priced editing services that promise the world and deliver nothing but mediocrity. It's a predatory practice that robs them of both their money and their agency.
Instead, let's bring the craft back into the classroom. We should be encouraging students to get their hands dirty with the actual labor of editing. Refining a manuscript, finding the right cadence, and learning how to prune a sentence until it's sharp-these aren't just academic exercises; they are vital skills for any professional path. College is the perfect, controlled environment to experiment, fail, and eventually master the technique of self-revision. Let's help them find their own voices rather than teaching them how to program a replacement.